Hitler,
Nazis, Socialism, and Rightwing Propaganda
David Klein
January 2011
For several years, the right wing has been equating nazism, the left,
and socialism. This is standard propaganda for Fox News and the Tea
Party which both denounce Obama as a socialist and at the same time
portray him visually with a Hitler mustache. Conservatives have
also argued that Jared Loughner -- the shooter of U.S.
Representative Gabrielle Giffords -- was influenced by leftwing
ideology
because his reading list included both Das Kapital by Karl Marx and
Hitler's Mein Kampf (without
mentioning another book on his list, We
the Living, by
Ayn Rand).
The conflation of nazism and
socialism has gone largely unchallenged by the media,
and through repetition it is becoming almost "common knowledge" in the
US, so I feel compelled to speak against it. I hope that others,
especially professors who have occasion to talk about it in
and out of class, will also speak against this vile propaganda.
The
basis of the conflation of nazism and socialism is the term "National
Socialism," a self description of the Nazis. "National
Socialism" includes the word
"socialism", but it is just a word. Hitler and the Nazis
outlawed socialism, and executed socialists and communists en masse,
even
before they started rounding up Jews.
In 1933, the Dachau concentration camp held socialists and leftists
exclusively. The Nazis arrested more than 11,000 Germans for "illegal
socialist activity" in 1936.
In the 1930s
and even beyond, nazism, in sharp contrast to socialism, was strongly
supported by leading capitalists and right wingers in the
US. Henry Ford, the
leading industrialist and auto maker, was a great admirer of the
nazis. When Henry Ford announced that he might run for
president in 1923,
the little-known Hitler told the Chicago Tribune that he would like to
send shock troops
to Chicago to assist in the campaign. Later in 1938, the year of
Kristallnacht, Ford was awarded the Grand Cross of the German Eagle,
the
highest civilian award given by the nazis. Ford accepted it with
pride, and Ford's company collaborated with the nazis as late as August
1942. General
Motors, Standard Oil, ITT, and Chase National Bank (later Chase
Manhattan Bank) among others also had major financial investments and
collaborations with
Nazi Germany.
J.
Edgar Hoover, the first director of the FBI (and virulently
anti-communist) was a great admirer of the nazis
and was a pen pal of
Heinrich Himmler (Reichsfuhrer of the Nazi SS, head of the Gestapo, and
second most powerful leader of the Nazi party). Hoover sent
Himmler a
personal invitation to attend the 1937 World Police Conference in
Montreal, and in 1938 welcomed one of Himmler's top aids to the
U.S.
In June 1939, when the Nazi SS was conducting savage attacks against
Jews, Gypsies, and homosexuals throughout Germany, Hoover personally
autographed a photo of himself and sent it in response to a request, to
KRIPO, the Nazi criminal police agency. He continued
communication
with Nazi police until December 4, 1941 (three days before Pearl
Harbor).*
Nazism
is a right wing ideology. It is violently racist, anti-socialist, and
it targets the political left for extermination. This is
underscored by Albert Einstein's embrace of socialism throughout his
life -- and in particular in his 1949 essay, Why Socialism?
-- along with the fact that
Einstein's name was included on a nazi death list with a bounty of
$50,000 offered for his assassination. If nazism really is
socialism, why would Einstein have identified himself as a socialist a
scant four years after WWII?
The current right
wing conflation of nazism and the left is sleazy. A more informed
population would view this as completely idiotic, but
unfortunately this propaganda
is becoming increasingly effective.
*For elaboration and references,
see Fred Jerome's excellent books, The
Einstein File and Einstein on
Race and Racism.